I have recently been in correspondence with Susan Johnson. Susan has a wide range of experience in animal welfare as well as in government in a number of countries including Bosnia. She worked in the US State Department and was instrumental in assisting a local NGO establish a model no kill shelter in Brcko, northeastern Bosnia.
Sadly, this shelter had to close after eight years because it was subject to sabotage, threats, abuse, theft and illegitimate lawsuits seeking to hold the operators financially liable for any and all dog bites in Brcko District. Susan Johnson’s experience with this shelter and in Bosnia in general has been invaluable in helping me understand the complexity and difficulty regarding animal welfare in the country. She says:
“Bosnia – and the Balkans in general – is a very tough place for humane and effective animal (dog) control, mainly because of the difficulty in finding any local authorities who are really interested in doing the right thing, or who actually know anything about what the right thing involves.
It is fundamentally a cultural problem which becomes a political problem for anyone who tackles it. Add to that the corruption and graft factor by which many at the municipal level have been skimming money from the budget for decades. There are consequently people and political parties with strong vested interests in the status quo. They resist change – including with threats, harassment, false accusations and other dirty tricks. If you look at the amount that different municipalities budget for stray dog control and the abysmal results you can see that a lot of fingers are in the pie. Considerable amounts are skimmed off with individuals getting considerable amounts ranging from a few thousand to $5000, $10,000 and in some case much more.
There are no controls on numbers so local authorities can say that “we collected 4000 dogs and euthanized them” when actually the number was far less. Or else they do kill them, but brutally – not through any Western concept of “euthanasia”: By clubbing, poisoning, shooting, starving and even just freezing them in industrial freezers. They have false invoices, inflated numbers, and all sorts of shenanigans.
Probably measurable progress will depend on some generational changes in local leadership and some public education that must come from Europe and the United States.
Other options are shining the sunlight on atrocities to “name and shame”, which depends on good investigative journalism by journalists who understand Bosnia and the Balkans. Not easy to find. Legal action is more iffy given the lack of independent judiciary in Bosnia.
All of this is why after about 8 years of trying to work this issue, I decided to implement an exit strategy and move the 101 Bazil dogs from Brcko (Birchko) District to a new site closer to the Belgrade international airport for easier access for international adoption, and in a municipality where local authorities might actually be interested. But this is northern Serbia, not Bosnia. I was pushed to do it last year because international supervision of Brcko was ending and there were local plans to take over the shelter and kill the dogs. Will the new site be better? Time will tell but initial signs are hopeful.
Not very encouraging I am sorry to say. It seems that Bosnia is not yet ready for even the beginning of a systemic solution. I am tempted to conclude that the best investment is in public education about responsible dog ownership and humane treatment of all animals. And finding ways to support any indigenous groups who are doing it right. Bosnia and the Balkans badly need some examples that are local.”
At the moment I only know of three shelters in Bosnia where there is a consistent track record of dogs being cared for well, one in Orašje, which is given support by Animal Kind’s Bosnia Animal Foundation (http://www.animal-kind.org/bosniaanimalfoundation.html) and two private shelters. More about dog shelters in the county can be found here.
What can we do? I don’t know. We can keep writing to the EU Parliament and organisations like the OIE World Organization for Animal Health, we can keep writing to the Bosnian authorities, and to western embassies in Sarajevo, and we can write to the international media in the hopes that the Bosnian government changes the desperate plight of stray dogs (and stray cats) in the country.
Currently Animal Welfare Advocates for Bosnia is focussing on homing the 20+ rescued stray dogs we are sponsoring in pension and foster. After this is complete we hope to raise funds for spay-neuter programes as this seems to be the only immediate step that can assist the situation from spiralling even more out of control than it is.
Horror Camps for Animals in Bosnia
Concentration Camp for Man’s Best Friend
Concentration Camp for Man’s Best Friend PART TWO
Mass Graves Found Near Dog “Shelter”
This site is dedicated to Vučko. Read his story and don’t let him have suffered and died in vain. Please help the stray dogs and cats in Bosnia-Herzegovina. The situation there is utterly dire, Vučko is but one amongst many horrifically abused animals. Go here to find out how to help them. Money is needed for food, medicine and foster housing. Even just one dollar or one euro will help.
Until some honest compassionate people are in authority it will be an uphill struggle for the few who do care about the Bosnian dogs!
Reblogged this on Time for Action.
So, is everyone saying the situation is hopeless in Boania?
Sounds like it.
La situation n’est pas bloquée , il suffit de le vouloir. Sauvons ces animaux de ces massacres , ils n’ont rien fait d’illégal . Ils n’ont juste pas eu de chance de naître dans un pays qui n’aime pas les animaux . Si çà perdure nous devons faire partir ce pays de la communauté Européenne , qui n’est pas un exemple pour la société .
I thank you for all you’re doing – I know there was supposed to be a vote recently on whether Bosnia is going to follow in Romania’s path of mass killing of strays – I can’t seem to find the results – although I’m sure I know – I will send a donation and again thank you.
Katherine, the vote when through the first ‘reading’ and was voted in. On the 7th November, there will be another debate, and then final voting on the 20th November. Thanks so much for your support!
Terrible!!! Concentration camps for human beings, for our best friends, dearest dogs – beings that help invalid persons. Homo sapiens sapiens must be shamed on them because of torture, sadism, murdering killing!!! Help dogs, help animals, help Nature – spm,etimes we are not human beings – we are undefined creatures those make evil and bad.
Help dogs and protect them. In Bosnia, in heart of Europe, cry God s creature – dogs, our best friends. Poet wrote poems about dogs, but we kill them – dogs and at the same time – poets. HELP DOGS – HELP OURSELVES!!!
I’m was project coordinator 2005/06 and I’m working for NGO ARKA on the project BaZil how is no kill shelter in Brcko district, first delta home I made in OHR where is was Mrs,Susan Johnson and this home we made for she dog Zina. Other delta home we made in Mc Govern base when is was USA army. When Mrs Susan Johnson back to home in USA all project is broken…